To Roth or Not to Roth, That is the Question

IRA stands for Individual Retirement Account. There are two primary types, Traditional IRA and Roth IRA. In this post I’m going to give you the basic information you need to help determine which type is best for you to contribute to annually.

Employee Retirement Income Security Act

In 1974 the Employee Retirement Income Security Act was signed into law and Traditional IRAs became available for the first time. These retirement accounts allow most taxpayers to make contributions to an account in their control and invested at their discretion. The money is contributed, in most cases, pre-tax, which allows a tax deduction to be taken on their tax return for that year. The money in the account then fluctuates based on the ebb and flow of the market and how it’s invested, with gains and losses occurring over time. These gains and losses are not realized on the tax return, but instead happen behind a tax-deferred barrier. This means the money can grow without being taxed right away.

The Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997:

The Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 introduced a new type of IRA, the Roth IRA. These operate somewhat similarly to Traditional IRAs, but with different rules. Most importantly is that your contributions are made post-tax rather than pre-tax, which means you do not deduct your contributions to the account on your tax return. You get NO upfront benefit from making contributions to the Roth IRA. The real benefit comes from the back end, when the account has been open for at least five years and you’ve reached age 59 ½. Upon taking distributions from the account then, the distributions are tax free. This means if you put $5,000 into the Roth IRA at age 50 and never put another dime in, then 10 years later fully distribute the account which is valued at, say, $6,000, you wouldn’t recognize any of the gain as income and would receive the full distribution tax-free. Obviously as the numbers scale up Roth IRAs just look better and better.

Ultimately you must decide if you want up front tax savings or wait for your savings on the back end. The Roth IRA has the greatest potential for overall savings as your account has unlimited potential growth. This makes it the IRA of choice for many people. However, there are two additional points you should consider before closing the book on this, and those are the compounding nature of tax savings and the concept of “principal investing power”.

Money is a finite resource, you only have so much of it. In the scenario in which you’re considering contributing $2,000 to an IRA, but you don’t yet know which one you want to contribute to, you can actually afford to contribute more to the Traditional IRA. By contributing $2,000 to a Traditional IRA, in a 22% tax bracket, you save $440 in taxes. This means that you could contribute $2,500 to the Traditional IRA, which would save you $550 in taxes, and then put that $550 in your bank account and it’s as if you were only out $1,950. When you contribute $2,000 to a Roth IRA your bank account is just out the $2,000.

Now regarding “principal investing power” I’ll use an example. If you invest $100,000 and I invest $10,000 and we both get a 5% rate of return on our investments, who earns more? You do, of course. The more you invest the more you earn, compounded enough times this becomes hugely relevant. Now apply that to our previous learning about compounded tax savings. The Traditional IRA holder contributed $2,500 and only lost $1,950 from their bank account while the Roth IRA holder contributed $2,000 and lost that $2,000 from their bank account.

The point here is that the Roth IRA has some huge advantages, but the Traditional IRA isn’t something to be dismissed either. Generally speaking, the younger you are the more attractive Roth IRAs should be to you. I generally prefer Roth IRAs over Traditional IRAs, but both have their place in the financial world.

The final consideration is whether you’re eligible to contribute to the IRA of your choice. Roth IRAs have an income limit of about $120,000 or single filers, $189,000 if you’re married. If your income is above that threshold your contribution may be limited or prohibited entirely. For Traditional IRAs it depends whether you have an employer sponsored retirement plan or not. If you do not, there is no income limitation for Traditional IRA contributions. You should consult with your tax advisor before making any contributions to a retirement account.

If you don’t have a tax advisor you should contact us at Molen & Associates. These types of conversations will occur naturally when discussing your finances each year with your advisor. If you have any additionally questions regarding this or any other subject please let us know by calling us at (281) 440-6279 or by email to info@molentax.com. We’re happy to give you a free 15-minute consultation to help you get your taxes and finances back on track.

Keep an eye out for our upcoming “Backdoor Roth IRA Strategy” follow up post, which will give you more insight into how you can contribute to a Roth IRA even if you exceed the income limitations.

The Molen & Associates Difference

Mike Forsyth

“Super helpful and timely. This is our first year with them and we look forward to trusting them with our taxes and business books for years to come.”

Caitlin Daulong

“Molen & Associates is amazing! They run an incredibly streamlined process, which makes filing taxes a breeze. So impressed with their attention to detail, organization, and swift execution every year. Cannot recommend them enough!”

Sy Sahrai

“I’ve been with Mr. Molen’s company for few years and I felt treated like family respect and dignity. They are caring, professional and honest, which hard to find these days. Love working with them.”

Should I Open an HSA?

Should I Open An HSA Account? Are you considering a Health Savings Account (HSA)? If so, it is vital to understand what exactly an HSA entails. With this guide, you'll learn all about it: the advantages of an HSA and how it can help you manage your medical expenses....

Personal Finance Tips for Young Adults

As someone who has been working for most of their life, I wish there was someone out there who had shown me the correct way to save money for my future. Now that I am in my 30s, I have been getting better at saving money, but there are some personal finance tips that...

How to Track Expenses

There are many different methodologies, tools, tips, and tricks for tracking expenses, and it ultimately depends on your lifestyle and how actively and accurately you want to track them. This is information I’ve pulled from other sources and compiled into a few...

How To Accurately Record Commuting Mileage and Increase Tax Deductions

Increase Tax Deductions With the Business-Mileage Rule Using the Business Mileage tax deduction can be tricky. There are lots of situations that count while others do not. We don’t like commuting mileage. You should dislike it, too. It’s personal. It’s not deductible....

Bookkeeping 101

As a new business owner, you will certainly have some responsibilities you won’t be able to avoid. One of those non-negotiable part of your business is producing financial statements. It can be overwhelming trying to master a topic such as bookkeeping but don’t worry...

Bankruptcy – Everything You Need to Know

Everything you need to know Filing for bankruptcy protection is considered a statement on your ability to repay your debt to your creditors. Filing for bankruptcy will also put a halt to foreclosure or legal actions against you, and it stops creditors from calling and...

Top Tax Tips for 2023

Tax Refunds May Be Smaller This Year Plan now to learn these 2023 tax tips avoid surprises in the future! If you’re expecting a tax refund in 2023, it may be smaller than last year, according to the IRS. Your annual balance is based on taxable income, calculated by...

What is an EA?

Have you ever seen the title EA next to a tax professional’s name and wonder what it means? Or maybe you’re familiar with the title and you’re curious about the differences between an EA and CPA? Either way, in this blog I will be answering these frequently asked...

History of Federal Income Tax Rates: 1913 – 2021

The United States federal government levies taxes on the income of its citizens and legal residents. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is the agency responsible for collecting these taxes.  Federal income tax rates have changed several times since 1913, when the...

Familiarize Yourself With Tax Terminology

Yes, I know, tax terminology feels like a whole new language. For most people all of tax forms can be even more confusing than a foreign language. What’s the difference between itemized deduction and standard deduction? What’s Income tax?  These words and more tax...

Request an Appointment Today

3 + 6 =

Call us at

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This